User talk:Document/List of Spartan-IIs

Missing some Spartans

I have a list I have compiled from here and other resources (mostly here) and from what I have compiled you are missing 11 Spartans from your list.

2 Unknown Attempted to escape the program with Ralph, Joseph, & Daisy in Halo Legends (unknown if alive I haven't seen it and Halopedia doesn't say)

Unnamed Spartan (Harvest) MIA (KIA), Harvest Campaign via Needler

Unnamed Spartan (Reach) MIA (KIA), Battle of Reach via three Covenant Cruisers' Plasma bombardments

3 Unknown MIA (KIA), Battle of Reach via Pelican rendered unusable in flight, had to jump out died upon impacting ground

3 Unknown MIA (KIA), Battle of Reach Died falling back to CASTLE Base

Keiichi-047 Status unknown

Hope that helps. --Revan's Exile 11:55, February 12, 2010 (UTC)

Thanks. The first two are listed as "Unknown Spartan - Killed in 2525"; I added them and Keiichi after I put up the page. I thought the unnamed Spartan at Harvest was Daisy, but I'll add them too for now (edit: done). The situation at Reach is harder, though; we have probable names and circumstances of death, but not which goes with which, so I'm lumping them all together. I'll try to make that clearer on the page. --Document 18:55, February 12, 2010 (UTC)

Update: Hopefully it's clearer now. --Document 19:41, February 12, 2010 (UTC)

Notes

• According to this forum post, "Halsey's journal helps explain the issues with the number of Spartan-IIs". I'll possibly if I'm around a copy sometime, but I doubt it; I've heard that line before. Likewise with the Fall of Reach comic.
• I haven't played Reach yet, so I don't know Jorge's exact date of death, though I imagine it's probably August 30.

--Document 01:53, 16 January 2011 (EST)