Talk:Jake Courage: Difference between revisions

Line 14:

To everyone, you should know that this is not purely canon as S-117 did not participate in the Second Battle of New Mombasa as stated by Bungie. If you already know about this, then refrain yourself from putting counter-claims...[[User:Subtank|H-107 Subtle Tank]] 21:07, 9 May 2008 (UTC)

As for the inaccuracies, let's try to have some willing suspension of disbelief. It is a made-up universe after all, and the creator of "Jake Courage" has the right to make him friends with the chief. Plus, a spiker does fire nail-like spikes, and MA5B and MA5C look similar and were used at the same time (2552). The one problem with the hardworking people here at Halopedia is that they are sometimes over-critical, and are reluctant to accept a new facet of the Halo universe if it disagrees even slightly with the established "Canon". Sometimes, imagination trumps canon. I think the addition of a civilian war photographer is a great idea.

Plus, I think Jake Courage is the protagonist from "Second Sunrise over New Mombasa", the last story in the halo graphic novel. After all, that guy was a controversial war photographer who was present in Mombasa.

@@ Line 14: / Line 14: @@
 To everyone, you should know that this is not purely canon as S-117 did not participate in the Second Battle of New Mombasa as stated by Bungie. If you already know about this, then refrain yourself from putting counter-claims...[[User:Subtank|H-107 Subtle Tank]] 21:07, 9 May 2008 (UTC)
+As for the inaccuracies, let's try to have some willing suspension of disbelief.  It is a made-up universe after all, and the creator of "Jake Courage" has the right to make him friends with the chief.  Plus, a spiker does fire nail-like spikes, and MA5B and MA5C look similar and were used at the same time (2552).  The one problem with the hardworking people here at Halopedia is that they are sometimes over-critical, and are reluctant to accept a new facet of the Halo universe if it disagrees even slightly with the established "Canon".  Sometimes, imagination trumps canon.   I think the addition of a civilian war photographer is a great idea.
+Plus, I think Jake Courage is the protagonist from "Second Sunrise over New Mombasa", the last story in the halo graphic novel.  After all, that guy was a controversial war photographer who was present in Mombasa.