Forum:Halopedia vote for Halo Nation to join us: Difference between revisions

Line 28:

#{{neutral}} - I largely echo the concerns that [[User:Nicmavr|Nicmavr]] raised in the comment section, in that unless the Wikia community is either re-formatted to serve a different function as to not continue to split traffic, such as by making it Halo community rather then Halo lore focused, or otherwise to ensure that Halopedia is used as the primary site for canonical information, that this split is fairly pointless. If anything, it would be negative, since it could leave the chance that the Wikia site will continue to get the most traffic and stay on the top of google searches, yet will cease to be updated or will only be updated by unqualified editors. I think it is imperative that prior to any decision being made, a concerete plan be made regarding what will happen to the Halo Nation wiki, and that it be verified that such plans will be not be interfered with by Wikia. My vote will remain neutral until anything changes; and I will change it to be support if it happens, or Oppose if it becomes apparent this cannot happen. [[User:Jabberwockxeno|Jabberwock xeno]] ([[User talk:Jabberwockxeno|talk]]) 15:15, 7 January 2019 (EST)

#{{neutral}} - Admittedly my opinion is mostly based on my past interactions with the Halo Nation admins. IMHO, it would be best if they joined like normal users instead of instantly being given a position of authority within a month. [[User:AlertFiend|AlertFiend]] - Warning, my comments may appear passive aggressive. ([[User talk:AlertFiend|Converse]]) 16:58, 7 January 2019 (EST)

:I actually agree with you here. I have had experience with very abusive admin(s). That said, I know a few good admins as well.

#{{neutral}} - As [[Forum:Halopedia_vote_for_Halo_Nation_to_join_us#Subtank|I have mentioned before]], we would still need to maintain the Wikia version so that we can manage the traffic between the two wikis. At the end of the day, Wikia paid for SEO whereas Halopedia relies on good will. See more on my comment to Nicmarv's below. — [[User:Subtank|subtank]] 11:27, 12 January 2019 (EST)

@@ Line 28: / Line 28: @@
 #{{neutral}} - I largely echo the concerns that [[User:Nicmavr|Nicmavr]] raised in the comment section, in that unless the Wikia community is either re-formatted to serve a different function as to not continue to split traffic, such as by making it Halo community rather then Halo lore focused, or otherwise to ensure that Halopedia is used as the primary site for canonical information, that this split is fairly pointless. If anything, it would be negative, since it could leave the chance that the Wikia site will continue to get the most traffic and stay on the top of google searches, yet will cease to be updated or will only be updated by unqualified editors. I think it is imperative that prior to any decision being made, a concerete plan be made regarding what will happen to the Halo Nation wiki, and that it be verified that such plans will be not be interfered with by Wikia. My vote will remain neutral until anything changes; and I will change it to be support if it happens, or Oppose if it becomes apparent this cannot happen. [[User:Jabberwockxeno|Jabberwock xeno]] ([[User talk:Jabberwockxeno|talk]]) 15:15, 7 January 2019 (EST)
 #{{neutral}} - Admittedly my opinion is mostly based on my past interactions with the Halo Nation admins. IMHO, it would be best if they joined like normal users instead of instantly being given a position of authority within a month. [[User:AlertFiend|AlertFiend]] - Warning, my comments may appear passive aggressive. <small>([[User talk:AlertFiend|Converse]]) </small> 16:58, 7 January 2019 (EST)
+:I actually agree with you here. I have had experience with very abusive admin(s). That said, I know a few good admins as well.
 #{{neutral}} -  As [[Forum:Halopedia_vote_for_Halo_Nation_to_join_us#Subtank|I have mentioned before]], we would still need to maintain the Wikia version so that we can manage the traffic between the two wikis. At the end of the day, Wikia paid for SEO whereas Halopedia relies on good will. See more on my comment to Nicmarv's below. — <span style="font-size:14px; font-family:Arial;">[[User:Subtank|<span style="color:#FF4F00;">subtank</span>]]</span>  11:27, 12 January 2019 (EST)