Talk:Operation: UPPER CUT: Difference between revisions

Line 18:

== Taking note of major, direct canon contradictions ==

All of the relevant Halo novels (and Halo 2) feature the orbital MAC platforms above Reach as major plot points and assets in the battle. This all becomes particularly bizarre when there isn't even a mention in Halo: Reach about the orbital MAC platforms being used to destroy the Covenant supercarrier, especially when both the novels and the games confirm that even one such orbital platform can make quick work of any Covenant capital ship, including a supercarrier.

All of the relevant Halo novels (and Halo 2) feature the orbital MAC platforms above Reach as major plot points and assets in the battle. This all becomes particularly bizarre when there isn't even a mention in Halo: Reach about the orbital MAC platforms being used to destroy the Covenant supercarrier, especially when both the novels and the games confirm that even one such orbital platform can make quick work of any Covenant capital ship, including a supercarrier. {{Unsigned|71.202.80.47}}

:What canon contradiction is there? They used the orbital MAC Platforms to destroy the Corvette attacking SWORD Base. And you don't take out [[Covenant Supercarrier|something that is as big as a city that would crush major population centers]] near said population centers. That is why they used a improvised slipspace bomb to destroy the Supercarrier. [[Talk:Halo:_Reach#Canonholes_in_Reach|Haven't we had these discussions before]]? Please sign your comments by typing <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>. Thank you!--[[File:Main-Superintendent.png|15px|link=User:Spartacus]] <tt>KEEP IT CLEAN</tt> [[User talk:Spartacus|'''Comm Line''']] [[Special:Contributions/Spartacus|'''Transmissions''']] 18:48, 9 June 2012 (EDT)

@@ Line 18: / Line 18: @@
 == Taking note of major, direct canon contradictions ==
-All of the relevant Halo novels (and Halo 2) feature the orbital MAC platforms above Reach as major plot points and assets in the battle. This all becomes particularly bizarre when there isn't even a mention in Halo: Reach about the orbital MAC platforms being used to destroy the Covenant supercarrier, especially when both the novels and the games confirm that even one such orbital platform can make quick work of any Covenant capital ship, including a supercarrier.
+All of the relevant Halo novels (and Halo 2) feature the orbital MAC platforms above Reach as major plot points and assets in the battle. This all becomes particularly bizarre when there isn't even a mention in Halo: Reach about the orbital MAC platforms being used to destroy the Covenant supercarrier, especially when both the novels and the games confirm that even one such orbital platform can make quick work of any Covenant capital ship, including a supercarrier. {{Unsigned|71.202.80.47}}
+:What canon contradiction is there? They used the orbital MAC Platforms to destroy the Corvette attacking SWORD Base. And you don't take out [[Covenant Supercarrier|something that is as big as a city that would crush major population centers]] near said population centers. That is why they used a improvised slipspace bomb to destroy the Supercarrier. [[Talk:Halo:_Reach#Canonholes_in_Reach|Haven't we had these discussions before]]? Please sign your comments by typing <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>. Thank you!--[[File:Main-Superintendent.png|15px|link=User:Spartacus]] <span style="color: #7BA05B; font-weight:bold; font-family: Arial; font-size: 10pt;"><tt>KEEP IT CLEAN</tt></span> <sup>[[User talk:Spartacus|<font color="Black"><u>'''Comm Line'''</u></font>]]</sup> <sub>[[Special:Contributions/Spartacus|<font color="Black"><u>'''Transmissions'''</u></font>]]</sub> 18:48, 9 June 2012 (EDT)