47,309
edits
Talk:Banished: Difference between revisions
→Objection to Banished classification as 'Mercenary'
(younger to other sections, so) |
BaconShelf (talk | contribs) |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 127: | Line 127: | ||
A bit further from the point, but still relevant, is the following observation: Although heavily militarised, the Banished seem to be more of a concept of a State then an actual military. It has a vast military true, but that has to be supported by something. An economy and homebase. | A bit further from the point, but still relevant, is the following observation: Although heavily militarised, the Banished seem to be more of a concept of a State then an actual military. It has a vast military true, but that has to be supported by something. An economy and homebase. | ||
[[User:Thijsbos|Thijsbos]] ([[User talk:Thijsbos|talk]]) 13:06, December 18, 2021 (EST) | [[User:Thijsbos|Thijsbos]] ([[User talk:Thijsbos|talk]]) 13:06, December 18, 2021 (EST) | ||
:I agree with this in principle, though I'd likely argue all of these labels have been correct at various points in time. The Banished when they were first created were certainly pirates and likely mercenaries - though the goals of Atriox shifted in the post-war to that of nation-building.[[User:BaconShelf|<span style="color:green;">BaconShelf</span>]] <span style="font-size:90%">([[User:BaconShelf|talk]])</span> 13:15, December 18, 2021 (EST) | |||
: Your objection goes against their official descriptions which is what we go off of for citations. They were first introduced as a '''"mercenary force"''' in ''[[Halo Wars 2]]'',<ref name="waypoint">[https://www.halowaypoint.com/en-us/games/halo-wars-2 '''Halo Waypoint''': ''Halo Wars 2''] ''"Atriox, the leader of a violent, mercenary force known as The Banished."''</ref> and ''[[Halo: Envoy]]'' mentioned that hiring the faction for work was possible.{{Ref/Novel|Halo Envoy|Quote=Anexus watched them depart. "We should send word to our fellow Jiralhanae clans. We could even call the Banished to us. Atriox would send us cruisers to transport these Sharquoi back to our homeworld. We will be safe forever."}} For a more recent and up to date description of them, ''[[Halo: Shadows of Reach]]'' still calls them '''"a horde of mercenary raiders"'''.{{Ref/Book|Id=Mercenary|Shadows of Reach|Chapter= 1|Quote=The second was a horde of mercenary raiders called simply the Banished.}} In ''[[Halo Infinite]]'' they are still composed of multiple mercenary clans as shown in targets section of the menu, so the description '''"mercenary raiders"''' still stands and should remain unless a new official source specifies that they are no longer mercenaries at all. [[User:Editorguy|Editorguy]] ([[User talk:Editorguy|talk]]) 13:47, December 18, 2021 (EST) | |||
{{Ref/Sources}} | |||
::While I agree overall, it's worth mentioning that your second quote doesn't imply that they're doing mercenary work. Given that Atriox's stance is one of wanting to promote and unify the Jiralhanae under one coherent banner to fend off their enemies in the Sangheili and humanity, this just sounds like Atriox being willing to help out Brute interests where possible. Less a mercenary contract and more shared goals/interests/alliance.[[User:BaconShelf|<span style="color:green;">BaconShelf</span>]] <span style="font-size:90%">([[User:BaconShelf|talk]])</span> 13:56, December 18, 2021 (EST) | |||