687
edits
Talk:Second Battle of Mombasa: Difference between revisions
m
no edit summary
SPARTAN-225 (talk | contribs) |
mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 67: | Line 67: | ||
I don't have said Encyclopedia, however i have heard that there are elements of Believe cited in the encyclopedia. Does this then pave the way for this article to become canon? It has been suggested above that it could be another Spartan in the battle, Maria perhaps? Think Troy, when Achilles cousin runs out in his armour: I'm pretty sure most people can't tell spartans apart and if it helped their fighting spirits a spartan, Maria, wouldn't stop to correct them. Real history has misrepresentations/mythology of events. This could be the ONI doctored version as the article itself suggests. I know this could border on fan-fiction, us trying to make it fit, but if it is in a canon source and there are peices that fit fairly easily with a little conjecture, why not? [[User talk:Classius|Classius]] 23:52, August 13, 2010 (UTC) | I don't have said Encyclopedia, however i have heard that there are elements of Believe cited in the encyclopedia. Does this then pave the way for this article to become canon? It has been suggested above that it could be another Spartan in the battle, Maria perhaps? Think Troy, when Achilles cousin runs out in his armour: I'm pretty sure most people can't tell spartans apart and if it helped their fighting spirits a spartan, Maria, wouldn't stop to correct them. Real history has misrepresentations/mythology of events. This could be the ONI doctored version as the article itself suggests. I know this could border on fan-fiction, us trying to make it fit, but if it is in a canon source and there are peices that fit fairly easily with a little conjecture, why not? [[User talk:Classius|Classius]] 23:52, August 13, 2010 (UTC) | ||
== Gonna say this very clearly == | |||
If the second battle of Mombasa, wasnt a real battle in the human-covenant war. What the HELL is the point of having it as an article, who thinks the article should be deleted? Cause all this article does is fuel speculation and pondering and that is NOT what halopedia is all about. | |||
Any counter-arguments feel free to post here first before further action is took --[[User talk:CookieMonstersayshello|CookieMonstersayshello]] 18:15, 4 June 2011 (EDT) | |||