2,719
edits
Talk:Project ASTER: Difference between revisions
→Pics or it didn't happen.
Durandal-217 (talk | contribs) |
Sona 'Demal (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
:::::As for "pics" if the first image on the article is valid and accurate to the canon, that is a great piece of evidence to look at which supports what I wrote given the location of of both stitches and bandages. Whether you wish to discuss the validity of the comic itself, is at your discretion. [[User talk:Durandal-217|Durandal-217]] 12:53, 29 January 2012 (EST) | :::::As for "pics" if the first image on the article is valid and accurate to the canon, that is a great piece of evidence to look at which supports what I wrote given the location of of both stitches and bandages. Whether you wish to discuss the validity of the comic itself, is at your discretion. [[User talk:Durandal-217|Durandal-217]] 12:53, 29 January 2012 (EST) | ||
::::::If you really want to get into the brain surgery metaphor, there is a clear difference. Brain surgery implies that the doctor is certain what he/she must do and causes a bit of deliberate injury before repairing it. But to compare it with the conjecture written in the article would be akin to cutting open someone's head for surgery without really knowing if you can put it back together. | |||
::::::If the images are from a Halo book, then it's valid. Speculation, however, should be removed since the Halo universe is still to this day vague about how technology works in the 26th century as well as how it differs to our lesser extent of knowledge today. But on a Halo canon site, conjecture shouldn't be put in the article, no matter how well-researched it may be, and is better off left out altogether. If people who have read the book know what was written, good for them. If they don't, it's not a good idea to leave potentially misleading "facts" in an article they rely on to be solid, dependable evidence from the Halo universe. <span style="font-family:calibri; text-shadow: black 0 4px 4px;">''[[User:Sona 'Demal|<abbr id="anId" class="jargon" style="color:offwhite;" title="My userpage"><font color=#005B99>I</font> <font color=#035E9D>a</font><font color=#0662A1>m</font> <font color=#0A66A5>i</font><font color=#0D69A8>n</font></abbr>]] [[User talk:Sona 'Demal|<abbr id="anId" class="jargon" style="color:offwhite;" title="My talk page"><font color=#116DAC>t</font><font color=#1470B0>h</font><font color=#117DCA>i</font><font color=#1B77B8>s</font> <font color=#1E7BBC>w</font><font color=#217EBF>o</font><font color=#2582C3>r</font><font color=#2886C7>l</font><font color=#2C89CB>d</font><font color=#2C89CB>,</font></abbr>]] [[Special:Contributions/Sona 'Demal|<abbr id="anId" class="jargon" style="color:offwhite;" title="My contributions"><font color=#3290D3>b</font><font color=#3694D7>u</font><font color=#3997DB>t</font> <font color=#3D9BDF>n</font><font color=#409FE3>o</font><font color=#43A2E6>t</font></abbr>]] [[Special:EmailUser/Sona 'Demal|<abbr id="anId" class="jargon" style="color:offwhite;" title="Email me"><font color=#47A6EA>o</font><font color=#4AA9EE>f</font> <font color=#4DADF2>i</font><font color=#54B4FA>t</font><font color=#57B7FD>.</font></abbr>]]''</span> | |||
22:38, 7 February 2012 (EST) | |||