Halopedia talk:Halopedian of the Month/07 2010

According to the Self-Voting Amendment, users may no longer vote for themselves until someone votes for them first.

Votes

 * Spirit of Fire - His contribution in Halopedia has been most appreciated: He has performed constructive additions, improve quality and readability of most articles we have in Halopedia and fought vandals alongside the Administration Team.- 5 ub7 ank (7alk ) 15:28, 4 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Spirit of Fire - As per Subtank, great guy to talk to, great contributor. Councillor   Nicmavr  -  Ascy   'Vamal  Light your way with honour! 15:42, 4 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Sith Venator - Recently, this Halopedian has shown his real potential. He presented a really great attitude, made constructive edits, rose among the "green" ranks of Halopedia, welcomed and helped new users, made it to the top 5 of the Top Users of the Month and Week, got Rollback (correct me if I'm wrong), and generally, he is a cheerful and simple guy, who really deserves some recognition. -  JEA13  [ iTalk  ] 11:18, 5 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Sith Venator - Very helpful, kind, and the Weekly Sith Hunt is fairly entertaining - Happy  hobo  -117  The Guy
 * Spirit of Fire - He deserves this many times over. His willingness to work hard plus his rare devotion to Halopedia supports this. — Co un  ci  ll  or   Ko  ug  er  ma  st  ers  14:19, 5 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Sith Venator - He's a good halopedian. Pretty helpful too.  Vadamee  ( Contibutions Profile ) 15:29, 5 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Spirit of Fire: per last month, which was he is good friend and a hard worker. Field   Master   Spartansniper  4  50  16:11, 5 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Sith Venator- he is really friendly and contributes alot to halopedia--Gubreez 20:44, 5 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Not enough article edits.


 * Spirit of Fire - As per Subtank and Kougermasters above. --
 * Spirit of Fire
 * Sith Venator --  Administrator  Specops306  -  Qur'a 'Morhek   Honour Light Your Way!  11:10, 6 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Spirit of Fire - Yep, that's right - I came out and voted. Rare thing. That's because I do genuinely believe that Spirit of Fire is a great user, and I'm not even officially his "friend"...! The 888th Avatar  (Talk) 11:20, 6 May 2009 (UTC)

Comments
Why are most users who don't vote on votings or comment on blogs considered "green"? Why are friends the only voting criteria in the HotM? I won't "post fingers" this time, but I know a lot of users who are far better that many of the users we believe to be veterans, or at least, "nice contributor, great guy"s.

Last month, I nominated Incendiary, who had made amazing contributions at the time, but without anybody noting it, and so without anybody supporting him. Of course, one of other nominees might deserve it more, but either way, nobody would even think of looking into it. Two months ago, I nominated Arbiter116, for the same reason I nominated Incendiary, but I quickly changed to another pre-nominated nominee because my opinion was influenced by everyone who voted for the more popular users. A great miskate of mine, which won't happen again. Please note here that none of these two users were my friends (at that time), I just voted for them because I looked into their contributions and considered their level of loyalty. Same for the Wavingstrider this month.

Not attending contests or votings doesn't mean less recognition or respect, instead means respect for the user in word for having a personal opinion on it and staying loyal to it. That's all I have to say. - JEA13 [ iTalk  ] 19:31, 4 May 2009 (UTC)


 * Firstly, I nominate Spirit of Fire not because of his popularity or because he's a friend (Everyone is my friend!). It is because his contributions since last year have been invaluable and when Halo Wars came out recently, he and a few other users cooperated with each other to help organise and fix articles related to the RTS game. Additionally, he's been nominated before in January (I think..) in the running with Spirit-of-HALO but didn't obtain the HoTM for January. Thus, these facts combined is the reason why I nominate him for this month.


 * Secondly, just because Spirit of Fire is nominated doesn't mean that other users are bad or worthless. Please keep in mind that the nominator can only nominate one user only. That said, other users would have a chance to be nominated for next month. What they should do is to contribute constructively and improve the quality of articles extensive and intensively.


 * Thirdly, the "popular voting" theory is plausible. The minorities would conform to the majorities choice. It's one of the core of sociology. Your example illustrates this.- 5 ub7 ank (7alk ) 19:48, 4 May 2009 (UTC)


 * About your second fact: What you said is exactly the same as what I said. There are always users who don't get nominated because nominators choose someone else, but this happens every month. I see users like Kougermasters, Spirit of Fire, Smoke, and most notably Nicvamr (congrats to all of you BTW!), who are nominated almost every month, while other users might deserve it more and could be nominated at their position, but that never happens, most possibly because of their low popularity level. I think I am the only one who nominates users never seen on HotMs before, like Incendiary and Sith Venator. Your point about the nominator being able to nominate one user at a time is right. Problem is, next time they would nominate a user who was nominated one or two months before by another nominator!


 * Also, contributing constructively and improve the quality of articles extensive and intensively gets boring and even annoying if there isn't any recognition for the user... - JEA13  [ iTalk  ] 11:44, 5 May 2009 (UTC)


 * I was only nominated once before last month. Before that I was practically invisible, haha. Smoke  12:27, 5 May 2009 (UTC)

Though this isn't really relevant, I despise the Weekly Sith Hunt. — Co un  ci  ll  or   Ko  ug  er  ma  st  ers  14:19, 5 May 2009 (UTC)


 * Cos your work has been invaluable Smoke.. Anyway, I was only nominated three times inside this page, not as many as what Jimmy said would make believe. 14:23, 5 May 2009 (UTC)


 * For me, being nominated three times in a HotM would be like getting all 7 Vidmaster Achievements! :P - JEA13  [ iTalk  ] 15:34, 5 May 2009 (UTC)


 * What about being nominated two times and winning the second time? A few Halopedians that I can think of bear that honor, though barely any of them got almost a tie in their first nomination. Why is everyone replying to my comment about the Sith Hunt...? So... only two nominees again this time? This should be interesting. — Co un  ci  ll  or   Ko  ug  er  ma  st  ers  00:01, 6 May 2009 (UTC)


 * I found being nominated for HOTM much more flattering than actually winning it. The fact that CT had just opened up an RFA also boosted my ego (and perhaps unintentionally my chances of winning), but just the fact that I was respected and liked enough for someone to nominate me was quite a feeling! Ah, simpler days... --  Administrator  Specops306  -  Qur'a 'Morhek   Honour Light Your Way!  11:18, 6 May 2009 (UTC)

I deeply apologize to disturb this conversation, but here comes more evidence to the fact that everyone votes with friends as a criteria.

Did you vote in the HotM? - me.

Never got to it,I will do it now though now that I have more friends that become it. - A good friend of mine.

Another example:

Did you vote in the HotM? - me (it was a board blast)

I would vote but I don't believe it would be valid since I neither know these users(something I hope to fix) nor have ever engaged in conversation with them(yes, I did read your comment and took your words seriously). - Another friend of mine.

Did you now see that all criteria in HotMs are friends? Why does every nomination and/or vote includes the words "a good friend" on them...?

Spirit of Fire is a great user, and I'm not even officially his "friend"...! - The 888th Avatar

Another example... No offense meant to any of these users! I was just giving examples. - JEA13  [ iTalk  ] 11:30, 6 May 2009 (UTC)


 * Okay, let's just face it, JEA. If you are voting on this page, you need to know the user you're voting for. If you don't like the user, then what on Earth are you doing on the page? Of course Halopedian of the Month is to an extent a popularity contest. The people who succeed on "User of the Month" contests on any wiki need to not only be a great contributor, but also be known to the community. We need to be realistic. The 888th Avatar  (Talk) 11:44, 6 May 2009 (UTC)


 * Don't like the user and don't know the user are two completely different things. When you vote in the elections of your country, do you know the one you voted in-person? You have just heard of his reputation or know about his contribution to your country. We may be a smaller community, but that has nothing to do with it. - JEA13  [ iTalk  ] 11:49, 6 May 2009 (UTC)


 * If you don't like the user, you won't come to this page to vote for him/her. If you don't know the user, you won't come either. When you vote in elections, you are informed of what the person is like. Not so here. You have to find out yourself, and the only foolproof way of doing that is interacting with the user in question. By the way, Halopedia is one of the biggest communities on Wikia. 316 users made more than five edits last month, and 22 made more than 100. That's a lot compared to most wikis on Wikia, and puts Halopedia in Wikia's top tier of wikis. The 888th Avatar  (Talk) 12:04, 6 May 2009 (UTC)


 * Well, It could be just me, but I don't need to interact with a user to know about his personality. I can understand his character by blog posts, popularity, or even grammar, and many other criterias. Of course interacting with someone is the best way, as is knowing about his rep, but trying to find people with low rep, having talked to them or not, is very good and shows everyone that there are more hidden users who can rise up suddenly. Cheers :) JEA13  [ iTalk  ] 12:12, 6 May 2009 (UTC)

Perhaps, if we want to honour newcomers, we could have a smaller "Newcomer of the Month" vote as well. But this may be unneeded. The 888th Avatar (Talk) 12:17, 6 May 2009 (UTC)


 * I like that Idea,might make users not go inactive. Sith-venator Wavingstrider [[Image:Red Team.jpg|50px]] ( Holonet ) 14:45, 6 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Yeah, that sounds good! - JEA13  [ iTalk  ] 14:47, 6 May 2009 (UTC)