Talk:James-005

Two articles?http://halo.wikia.com/wiki/Spartan-James--User:JohnSpartan117 09:28, 16 December 2006 (UTC)

What happened to the conjecture blurb? I thought there was one stating that, though there has never been a given Spartan tag for James, due to Bungie's general humor it was believed his tag was SPARTAN-007. Was that removed, or is it on another page entirely? Jimmy-San 00:48, 16 January 2008 (UTC)

Who keeps trying to add that James was purposely MIA? there are several KEY differences beteen Kurts abduction and the disappearance of James, most notably THE COVENANT. The UNSC would need to find James and recover him, something I think the Covenant would throw a spanner into the planning of. Even if Ackerson was planning that, I don't think he'd do it during the fight to save Reach.  Specops306 ,  Kora 'Morhek  03:47, 7 February 2008 (UTC)

James Appears in reach game

 * What is believed to bee James' body has been seen floating in space during the Halo: Reach Trailer http://uk.xbox360.ign.com/dor/objects/14276699/halo-project/videos/haloreach_spc_rewindtheater.html

Ok... lets see.... its not HIM, case closed.

How are you sure it's not him?

Because I dont think he is dead at this time.

Blade bane 23:12, 23 June 2009 (UTC)Blade bane

Its Debris...

Both of you have beliefs but they can be both proven wrong and can you prove it's debris without a doubt?-76.21.106.232

You cant prove me wrong, because what I said is previously established canon. And can you prove it is James with out a doubt?

Blade bane 23:20, 23 June 2009 (UTC)Blade bane

No I can't however the people in the video believe it's James who was left out in space ,because they couldn't find him, to die. The trailer seems to be a time lapse of the fall of reach from first contact to James' death if that's him to the planet being glassed. unless you know he survived all that somehow and the article is not being kept up to date which you should fix if it is the truth, that most likely is his body-76.21.106.232

Most likely isnt good enough at halopedia. We need cited facts, and speculation isn't allowed. If sometime during the release bungie says its him, then it will be posted here. Until then it wont.

Blade bane 23:32, 23 June 2009 (UTC)Blade bane

I'm going to ask bungie anyway if that's the truth about cited facts you might want to remove that bit about the left arm since neithe are confirmed and thus also fan spec-76.21.106.232
 * Well, let's see...first he has to arms, then one is blown off, then he has two arms again. Yep, he has a robotic or flash-cloned arm. This is obvious, not fan speculation. "Fan Speculation" is like saying that James appears in this game because he was in the battle of Reach. We have no proof. Do we have proof that you even play as a SPARTAN right now? And how would he get to Reach? Case Closed. --  Fore  run  ner  23:44, 23 June 2009 (UTC)

I think this could actually be a worthwhile question. I can ask Commander Tony if he gets a Q & A with the devs to ask this. And the thing with the left arm is in the book "The fall of reach". A hunter shoots his arm off.

Blade bane 23:41, 23 June 2009 (UTC)Blade bane

I'm not talking about that part since that's in the book but the speculation on how it was replaced which you said yourself "and speculation isn't allowed" which should include the trivia section and if it doesn't why not this?-76.21.106.232 23:45, 23 June 2009 (UTC)
 * When? Speculation is allowed, so long as there is something to back it up.-- Fore  run  ner  23:46, 23 June 2009 (UTC)