Forum:Sergeant Stacker vs. Gunnery Sergeant Stacker

Has Bungie told us whether or not Sergeant Stacker (Halo 1) from H:CE is the same as Gunnery Sergeant Pete Stacker from Halo 2? All evidence points to the Southern-accented Stacker being the same person as Pete. Also, Johnson is in all three Halo games, so why not the other Sergeant from the first game?--CT-5619 helmet comlink 21:45, 12 June 2007 (UTC)

I think they are just the same guy, both have the same voice actor, they kinda look the same, and have the same name. Thats why I think they are the same.(CommanderTony 22:10, 12 June 2007 (UTC))

I too think they're the same person for the same reasons. I also believe that because Bungie has kept the story consistant so far, right?

I think we should merge. -- UoH  General Blemo •(Talk) •(Contributions)

I don't believe so. Sergeant Stacker from Halo 1 was never given an exact place in Halo 1, the namesake was just created to describe the persona of a typical Sergeant. As you can see from his article, the places where "Sergeant Stacker" is seen in game are actually filled by other characters; Parker, Waller, etc. Pete Stacker is an ODST, while Sergeant Stacker is a regular Marine. Besides, the Chief and Johnson were the only ones to survive Halo; how would Stacker have managed escaped Halo, joined the ODSTs, AND get a promotion and get a new face in the time between Halo 1 and Halo 2 while not being mentioned anywhere along the way? -- ED ( talk )(gaming) 03:18, 21 June 2007 (UTC)

I personally believe that it can't be the same. He would have been listed as one of the survivors on the Pelican during OPERATION:FIRST STRIKE, which he wasn't. --Lordofmonsterisland 16:16, 21 June 2007 (UTC)

Um... ED... Johnson and Chief weren't the only ones to survive halo... there were about... 4 other people and the SPARTAN in cryo. AJ 14:18, 18 October 2007 (UTC)

Yes, but how many of them made it back to Earth? Johnson, John, and three other SPARTAN-IIs make it back to Earth. Of them, only John and Johnson were present on Halo (Fred and Will were on Reach, Linda was floating about in her Cryo tube in space, Haverson and Whitcomb sacrafice themselves to destroy the Covenant fleet near the Unyielding Heirophent, Polaski is killed by plasma, and Locklear commits suicide. Grace, Li, and Anton are all killed between Reach and Earth, and Halsey and Kelly go to Onyx, but never were on Halo. Thus, Johnson and John are the only survivors of Halo to make it back to Earth).
 * -- Master Gunnery Sergeant  Hank J Wimbleton IV COMHalo: Galaxy 06:36, 24 October 2007 (UTC)

I was talking about who made it off HALO! Not the guys who made it off of Reach! The Sarge  Comm CSV 21:13, 25 October 2007 (UTC)